For most property investors, entering the real estate market can be especially challenging, with potential pitfalls around every corner. Whether you’re buying, renting, or refinancing a mortgage, the last thing you want to worry about is becoming a victim of fraud.
Unfortunately, criminals have grown increasingly sophisticated in preying on housing consumers, adding extra stress and risk to an already complicated process. In 2023 alone, over 9,500 internet-based real estate scams were reported to the FBI, resulting in more than US $ 145 million in losses — most of which will never be recovered.
Real estate scams are a global concern, and while the Cayman Islands have strong protections in place, occasional incidents do still occur. This highlights the importance of staying vigilant and proactive at all times. Being aware of potential threats and implementing safeguards helps ensure that buyers, sellers, and real estate professionals can continue to navigate transactions securely.
Here are some of the most common real estate scams and how to steer clear of them.
Escrow Wire Fraud
The Scam: Scammers intercept communication between you and your escrow company, providing fake wire transfer instructions that divert your money to an offshore account. These fraudulent instructions are sent via email, phone, or text, mimicking the legitimate escrow company with only minor alterations in the contact details, making them easy to overlook.
Prevention: Before sending money, always verify wire instructions with a live person using a phone number from your original documents—not from an email or text link. Be wary of any last-minute changes to instructions, and confirm the details directly with your escrow agent.
Loan Flipping
The Scam: Scammers target vulnerable homeowners, particularly seniors or those who don’t have good credit scores, convincing them to refinance their mortgage repeatedly. Each refinance brings in higher fees for the lender while reducing the homeowner’s equity, eventually leading to unmanageable payments.
Prevention: Be cautious if you’re being approached by lenders offering unsolicited refinancing deals. Stick to reputable banks or lenders you know, and involve a trusted family member or advisor in any discussions, especially for the elderly. Review any loan documents carefully, and be wary of high fees and interest rates.
Predatory Lending
The Scam: Just like in loan flipping, predatory lenders prey on vat-risk borrowers, offering loans with exorbitant interest rates and hidden fees. These high-cost loans often lead to foreclosure when borrowers can no longer keep up with their payments.
Prevention: Educate yourself about current mortgage rates and compare offers from multiple lenders. Don’t rush into a deal; consult with a financial advisor or real estate professional to ensure that the terms are fair and within industry standards. Avoid lenders that solicit you aggressively or offer terms that seem too good to be true.
Foreclosure Relief Scams
The Scam: When homeowners fall behind on their mortgage payments, scammers promise foreclosure relief in exchange for large upfront fees. They claim they’ll negotiate with the lender or reduce mortgage payments but often disappear with the money, leaving the homeowner in worse financial shape.
Prevention: The best way to avoid foreclosure is to work directly with your lender or with an accredited housing counselor. Never trust someone who tells you not to communicate with your lender. Always confirm the legitimacy of any assistance programs through your lender or government housing agencies.
Fake Listings
The Scam: Fraudsters create fake ads using stolen images and property descriptions. They lure renters with unrealistically low prices and demand upfront deposits before the renter can see the property. In many cases, the property either doesn’t exist or is already occupied.
Prevention: Always visit the property in person before making any payments. Avoid anyone who asks for a deposit before letting you see the property. Do your research to verify the legitimacy of the property owner by checking public records and speaking directly with them before proceeding with any transaction.
Deed Fraud
The Scam: In deed fraud, scammers forge documents to transfer the title of a property to themselves, often targeting vacant or unoccupied properties. Victims may not realize they’ve been scammed until they receive notices for unpaid taxes or attempt to sell the property.
Prevention: Regularly review public records for any changes to your property deed, and keep an eye on your credit for any unusual activity to detect potential fraud early.
While owner’s title insurance can also offer extra protection against deed fraud, it’s often unnecessary in the Cayman Islands. The Caymanian government’s clear title guarantee ensures that property purchases are secure and financially sound, reducing the need for additional insurance.
Real Estate Investor Scams
The Scam: Investment property scams come in many forms, including false property valuations, timeshare scams, or fraudulent investment seminars. These scams often promise high returns on investment but lead to financial loss once the fraudster disappears with the investor’s money.
Prevention: Always conduct thorough due diligence before investing in real estate. Research the property, verify the credentials of the seller or seminar leader, and consult with a financial advisor or a local real estate expert. Be skeptical of promises of guaranteed high returns with little effort.
Moving Scams
The Scam: Moving scams occur when fraudulent moving companies provide lowball estimates but demand significantly more money once your belongings are loaded onto the truck. In some cases, they may even hold your items hostage until you pay up.
Prevention: Before hiring a moving company, check their reviews and ensure they are licensed and insured. Get written estimates from at least three companies, and never pay a large deposit upfront. Ensure that the moving company is reputable by checking with the Better Business Bureau (or similar organizations) and searching for legitimate online reviews.
Sellers are also at risk
Real estate scammers target both buyers and sellers, so it’s crucial to remain vigilant. Robert Totten, a broker and co-owner of ERA Cayman Islands, highlights a common scam where potential buyers inquire about properties without ever visiting them. He advises sellers to be cautious with such inquiries, particularly from those with no ties to the island. “We have received inquiries stating they wanted to purchase a particular property without even seeing it. These end up being mostly scams and waste the owner’s time.”
To avoid falling victim to scams, Robert emphasizes the importance of thoroughly verifying everyone involved in a transaction. “It is the realtor’s responsibility to verify if the customer is legit and has the means to purchase a property,” he says. He stresses that real estate professionals must conduct detailed background checks and ensure that funds are managed securely to protect all parties.
Ensuring a secure online environment
In addition to these practices, Robert emphasizes the importance of real estate companies investing in robust technical security measures. Implementing advanced security protocols for websites and email systems is crucial for effectively safeguarding against fraud.
“For the ERA Cayman website, we employ several strategies to help protect our clients and maintain a secure digital environment,” says Fevi Yu, founder of WOWebsites, a US-based web and SEO company. “We use SSL encryption to secure data transmitted between users and our website. Daily security audits are conducted to identify and address any vulnerabilities. Regular updates keep our software current, minimizing security risks. Anti-malware and anti-virus solutions provide ongoing protection against threats, while strict access controls ensure that only authorized personnel can access the website. Additionally, we use Cloudflare for DNS management, offering fast and secure DNS services.”
“For email security, we implement SPF, DKIM, and DMARC protocols to prevent email spoofing. We also rely on Gmail’s features, including TLS encryption for secure email transmission, advanced spam filters to detect and block phishing attempts, and regular security updates to protect against new threats.”
By adopting these preventive measures, ERA Cayman aims to protect its clients and maintain a secure, trustworthy online environment.
How to identify red flags in transactions
Spotting real estate scams often comes down to recognizing a few key red flags, especially for first-time buyers who may be unfamiliar with the process. Be cautious of any situation where proper documentation is missing, or someone requests payment before paperwork is signed. Beware of high-pressure tactics that push you to act immediately without time to think critically. Lastly, trust your instincts—if an offer seems unrealistically good, like 0% interest or no fees, it’s likely a scam. Staying alert to these signs can help protect you from potential fraud.
Real estate scams can be devastating, but with vigilance and proper precautions, you can avoid becoming a victim. Always verify information directly with trusted professionals, be skeptical of deals that seem too good to be true, and never rush into a transaction without doing your homework.
Taking the time to double-check details and working with experienced real estate agents like Team ERA Cayman could save you from significant financial loss and heartache. If you are in the market for property investment in the Cayman Islands, we would be happy to assist you.
Inquire for More Information
ERA Blogs are written in-house. It is a team effort and we all contribute our ideas and suggestions. ERA is a diverse Team of Real Estate Agents who each have specialties. We have Seven Mile Beach Real Estate Experts, Beachfront Real Estate Experts, Commercial Real Estate Experts and everything you could possibly need when looking for a Real Estate Team. The blog is summarized and submitted by ERA’s Web Team.